my-toy-santa

You May Like

LARGE 1950's Rubber Face 24" Santa Plush Doll My Toy  Stuffed  MCM Christmas
LARGE 1950's Rubber Face 24" Santa Plush Doll My Toy Stuffed MCM Christmas

$145.00

View Details
Vintage My Toy Santa Claus 20" Velveteen Rubber Face  Christmas Doll Plush 1950s
Vintage My Toy Santa Claus 20" Velveteen Rubber Face Christmas Doll Plush 1950s

$79.99

View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24" Size Rushton Style
Vintage 1950's My Toy Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24" Size Rushton Style

$98.50

View Details
VTG 1950s My Toy Rubber Face Plush Santa Claus 24" Doll Ruston Style
VTG 1950s My Toy Rubber Face Plush Santa Claus 24" Doll Ruston Style

$150.00

View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa with Rubber Face, Hands, & Boots.
Vintage 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa with Rubber Face, Hands, & Boots.

$63.00

View Details
Vintage MY Toy Christmas Large 24" Stuffed SANTA Plush Rubber Face Hands Boots
Vintage MY Toy Christmas Large 24" Stuffed SANTA Plush Rubber Face Hands Boots

$70.00

View Details
"MY TOY"~ SANTA CLAUS MUSICAL Plush Doll~ Rubber Face ~1950's-60's Vintage
"MY TOY"~ SANTA CLAUS MUSICAL Plush Doll~ Rubber Face ~1950's-60's Vintage

$79.00

View Details
Vtg 18” Rushton/My Toy ?Santa Claus Plush Christmas Rubber Face Original Belt
Vtg 18” Rushton/My Toy ?Santa Claus Plush Christmas Rubber Face Original Belt

$149.00

View Details
Vintage Rare Large Plush 32” Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas My Toy 1960
Vintage Rare Large Plush 32” Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas My Toy 1960

$175.99

View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Lot Of 2 Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Christmas Rushton Dolls
Vtg 50s My Toy Lot Of 2 Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Christmas Rushton Dolls

$149.99

View Details
Vtg 50’s Large 24” Santa Rubber Face Hands Boots-Rushton ,My Toy ,Coca-Cola?
Vtg 50’s Large 24” Santa Rubber Face Hands Boots-Rushton ,My Toy ,Coca-Cola?

$76.00

View Details
24” Vintage MCM MY TOY Plush Stuffed Santa Rubber Face Hands Boots🎅🏻
24” Vintage MCM MY TOY Plush Stuffed Santa Rubber Face Hands Boots🎅🏻

$125.00

View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy SANTA CLAUS Plush Rubber Face Doll Rushton Style Large 20"
Vintage 1950's My Toy SANTA CLAUS Plush Rubber Face Doll Rushton Style Large 20"

$74.99

View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Rubber Face Rushton Style 24”
Vintage 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Rubber Face Rushton Style 24”

$80.00

View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era

$179.99

View Details
Vintage Rubber Face Large Santa Claus Doll Plush “My Toy”  22" 1960s
Vintage Rubber Face Large Santa Claus Doll Plush “My Toy” 22" 1960s

$114.45

View Details
Vintage Rubber Face Santa Doll My Toy
Vintage Rubber Face Santa Doll My Toy

$125.00

View Details
Vtg 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Push Rubber Face Hands Boot Ruston Style
Vtg 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Push Rubber Face Hands Boot Ruston Style

$124.99

View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24" Size Rushton Style
Vintage 1950's My Toy Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24" Size Rushton Style

$115.00

View Details
Vintage Christmas Santa Plush Doll Rubber Face & Plastic Boots My Toy 24" 1950's
Vintage Christmas Santa Plush Doll Rubber Face & Plastic Boots My Toy 24" 1950's

$250.00

View Details
Vintage MY TOY Musical Santa Claus Plush Stuffed w/ Rubber Face Doll - 15" Tall
Vintage MY TOY Musical Santa Claus Plush Stuffed w/ Rubber Face Doll - 15" Tall

$79.99

View Details
Vintage Rubber Face Superior Toy Santa Korea Plush Doll Christmas Mcm Kitschy
Vintage Rubber Face Superior Toy Santa Korea Plush Doll Christmas Mcm Kitschy

$48.00

View Details
Tekky Toys Pull My Finger Santa Claus Plush 2004 Electronic Talking Farting Tags
Tekky Toys Pull My Finger Santa Claus Plush 2004 Electronic Talking Farting Tags

$39.99

View Details
My Toy Rubber faced plush Santa Clause 30" vintage rare
My Toy Rubber faced plush Santa Clause 30" vintage rare

$100.00

View Details
Tekky Toys Pull My Finger Santa Claus Plush 2002 Electronic Talking Farting
Tekky Toys Pull My Finger Santa Claus Plush 2002 Electronic Talking Farting

$38.00

View Details
Vintage 1950s Santa Claus My Toy Plush Rubber Face Doll With Original Tag
Vintage 1950s Santa Claus My Toy Plush Rubber Face Doll With Original Tag

$199.99

View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 24"
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 24"

$145.00

View Details
Vintage Rubber faced Santa My toy plush pals Vinyl 18" Tall
Vintage Rubber faced Santa My toy plush pals Vinyl 18" Tall

$124.95

View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy

$92.99

View Details
Vtg 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Push Rubber Face Hands Boot Ruston Style
Vtg 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Push Rubber Face Hands Boot Ruston Style

$189.97

View Details
My Melo Avail Plush Toy Keychain Santa
My Melo Avail Plush Toy Keychain Santa

$72.90

View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Festive Music Playing Toy Lights & Sounds Christmas
Step 2 My First Snowman Festive Music Playing Toy Lights & Sounds Christmas

$80.00

View Details
Vintage Large Plush 32” Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas Plastic 60s MCM Decor
Vintage Large Plush 32” Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas Plastic 60s MCM Decor

$69.99

View Details
Stamped “1966 My Toy Co” Plush W/ Rubber Face Santa In Perfect Condition 15”.
Stamped “1966 My Toy Co” Plush W/ Rubber Face Santa In Perfect Condition 15”.

$89.00

View Details
Vintage Santa Claus with Rubber Face,1950’s My Toy Santa, Christmas Kitsch
Vintage Santa Claus with Rubber Face,1950’s My Toy Santa, Christmas Kitsch

$75.00

View Details
My First Santa 2000 Plush Rattle Baby Pink Stuffed Green 1st Main Joy Toy
My First Santa 2000 Plush Rattle Baby Pink Stuffed Green 1st Main Joy Toy

$25.00

View Details
Step2 ~ Step 2 ~ My First Advent Calendar ~ 25 Day Christmas Countdown ~ Retired
Step2 ~ Step 2 ~ My First Advent Calendar ~ 25 Day Christmas Countdown ~ Retired

$74.99

View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Toy Music Lights Holiday Christmas Pretend Play NEW!!!
Step 2 My First Snowman Toy Music Lights Holiday Christmas Pretend Play NEW!!!

$55.96

View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy

$114.99

View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy

$91.45

View Details
NIB My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer  7” Ornaments Toys
NIB My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys

$12.00

View Details
MY FIRST SANTA CHRISTMAS RATTLE ?MAIN JOY? 2000 PLUSH TOY DOLL Pink Mint Green
MY FIRST SANTA CHRISTMAS RATTLE ?MAIN JOY? 2000 PLUSH TOY DOLL Pink Mint Green

$29.99

View Details
MCM Vintage Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas Plush Large Stuffed 18" Smiling
MCM Vintage Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas Plush Large Stuffed 18" Smiling

$155.00

View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 24”
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 24”

$149.95

View Details
Vintage MY TOY Stuffed Plush Santa Claus Rubber Hands Face Boots  927
Vintage MY TOY Stuffed Plush Santa Claus Rubber Hands Face Boots 927

$110.00

View Details
Pull My Finger Santa Plush Holiday Christmas Prank White Elephant Toy 7 In Gifts
Pull My Finger Santa Plush Holiday Christmas Prank White Elephant Toy 7 In Gifts

$22.77

View Details
Santa's Workshop Plush Playset "My First Christmas" by Genius Babies
Santa's Workshop Plush Playset "My First Christmas" by Genius Babies

$12.96

View Details
Vintage My Toy 1950s Santa Claus doll-kitschy-Christmas-mid century
Vintage My Toy 1950s Santa Claus doll-kitschy-Christmas-mid century

$150.00

View Details
NIB My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys
NIB My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys

$9.99

View Details
Pearhead My First Christmas Santa Claus Security Blanket Plush Baby Toy Soft 13”
Pearhead My First Christmas Santa Claus Security Blanket Plush Baby Toy Soft 13”

$8.00

View Details
1950s Rushton Toy Rubber Face Hands Boots Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 30”
1950s Rushton Toy Rubber Face Hands Boots Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 30”

$89.99

View Details
Sanrio Original My Melody Santa Claus Plush Toy 8"H  (Christmas 2021) Japan
Sanrio Original My Melody Santa Claus Plush Toy 8"H (Christmas 2021) Japan

$42.87

View Details
Step2 My First Advent Calendar 25 Day Christmas Countdown Retired Brand New
Step2 My First Advent Calendar 25 Day Christmas Countdown Retired Brand New

$90.00

View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Festive Music Playing Toy Lights & Sounds Christmas
Step 2 My First Snowman Festive Music Playing Toy Lights & Sounds Christmas

$49.99

View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Music Lights Holiday Xmas Pretend Play-NEW-FAST SHIP!
Step 2 My First Snowman Music Lights Holiday Xmas Pretend Play-NEW-FAST SHIP!

$99.98

View Details
SANRIO 8" MY MELODY Holiday Christmas Pink Santa Hat PLUSH NEW
SANRIO 8" MY MELODY Holiday Christmas Pink Santa Hat PLUSH NEW

$13.17

View Details
Antique Toy Rubber Face Hands Boots Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24"
Antique Toy Rubber Face Hands Boots Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24"

$81.17

View Details
BARK BOX Ho Ho Hold My Cookies DOG TOY Plush Multi NWT M-L Santa Claus Christmas
BARK BOX Ho Ho Hold My Cookies DOG TOY Plush Multi NWT M-L Santa Claus Christmas

$24.58

View Details
My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys
My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys

$12.00

View Details
Christmas Lovey Santa My First Baby Starters  Soothing Soft Security Baby Toy
Christmas Lovey Santa My First Baby Starters Soothing Soft Security Baby Toy

$3.27

View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Music Lights Holiday Xmas Pretend Play-NEW-FAST SHIP!
Step 2 My First Snowman Music Lights Holiday Xmas Pretend Play-NEW-FAST SHIP!

$78.00

View Details
Kellytoy Baby My 1st Christmas Santa Teddy Bear Plush Rattle Crinkle Ears 10"
Kellytoy Baby My 1st Christmas Santa Teddy Bear Plush Rattle Crinkle Ears 10"

$12.95

View Details
Vintage Bantam Santa Plush Rattle Red Stuffed Baby Toy Lovey My 1st Xmas HTF 8”
Vintage Bantam Santa Plush Rattle Red Stuffed Baby Toy Lovey My 1st Xmas HTF 8”

$59.99

View Details
Baby Ganz “ My First Christmas “ Santa Outfit Plush Doll Rattle 9”
Baby Ganz “ My First Christmas “ Santa Outfit Plush Doll Rattle 9”

$7.50

View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 25"
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 25"

$125.00

View Details
ANTIQUE CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT ~DOG IN SANTA TOY BAG~ "MY DARLING" on Belly
ANTIQUE CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT ~DOG IN SANTA TOY BAG~ "MY DARLING" on Belly

$22.99

View Details
My Life As Holiday Play Set Christmas Tree Fireplace For Use With 18" Dolls TM1
My Life As Holiday Play Set Christmas Tree Fireplace For Use With 18" Dolls TM1

$63.99

View Details
Phidal My Busy Books Santa Claus Toy Mini Figure Christmas Holiday Ornament Rare
Phidal My Busy Books Santa Claus Toy Mini Figure Christmas Holiday Ornament Rare

$3.99

View Details
My 1st Christmas Santa Snuggle Buddy Lovey Crib Activity Toy + Pacifier Clip
My 1st Christmas Santa Snuggle Buddy Lovey Crib Activity Toy + Pacifier Clip

$8.79

View Details
My Little Pony Plush Blue Christmas Santa Hat Scarf Pinkie Pie Stuffed Animal 12
My Little Pony Plush Blue Christmas Santa Hat Scarf Pinkie Pie Stuffed Animal 12

$18.69

View Details
Baby Gund My First Santa Lovie Plush Toy Rattle 11" Lovey Soft w/Sewn eyes
Baby Gund My First Santa Lovie Plush Toy Rattle 11" Lovey Soft w/Sewn eyes

$9.99

View Details
Rare VTG 2011 Tekky Toys “My Ding-a-ling” Animated Elf New
Rare VTG 2011 Tekky Toys “My Ding-a-ling” Animated Elf New

$142.50

View Details
Jolijou Paris My First Santa Doll Plush Christmas Red Lovey NIB Stuffed 7.5" Toy
Jolijou Paris My First Santa Doll Plush Christmas Red Lovey NIB Stuffed 7.5" Toy

$27.00

View Details
My Favorite Things  Vintage Plush Wieghted Velvet Santa Claus w/bag Hand Made
My Favorite Things Vintage Plush Wieghted Velvet Santa Claus w/bag Hand Made

$24.99

View Details
Gotta Getta Gund My Name is Santa Stuffed Plush 12 Inch
Gotta Getta Gund My Name is Santa Stuffed Plush 12 Inch

$13.72

View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Toy Music Lights Holiday Christmas Pretend Play Holiday
Step 2 My First Snowman Toy Music Lights Holiday Christmas Pretend Play Holiday

$35.00

View Details
My Little Pony Christmas Santa Hat Pinkie Pie 6" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2016
My Little Pony Christmas Santa Hat Pinkie Pie 6" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2016

$3.99

View Details
VTG BANTAM CHRISTMAS SANTA CLAUS DOLL PLUSH TOY BIG "LISTEN TO MY CHIMES"
VTG BANTAM CHRISTMAS SANTA CLAUS DOLL PLUSH TOY BIG "LISTEN TO MY CHIMES"

$16.14

View Details
VINTAGE CERAMIC SANTA KNOME FABRIC HAT TOY SACK KOREA 5"
VINTAGE CERAMIC SANTA KNOME FABRIC HAT TOY SACK KOREA 5"

$14.99

View Details
Teddy Bear Plush by Gund:  "My First Christmas" 16" with Santa Suit
Teddy Bear Plush by Gund: "My First Christmas" 16" with Santa Suit

$9.45

View Details
Vintage 10 in tall Christmas Plastic Face Santa Claus Plush Posable Stuffed Doll
Vintage 10 in tall Christmas Plastic Face Santa Claus Plush Posable Stuffed Doll

$24.25

View Details
My Little Pony Twilight Sparkle 6-Inch Plush Stuffed Toy with Santa Hat
My Little Pony Twilight Sparkle 6-Inch Plush Stuffed Toy with Santa Hat

$5.99

View Details
Gund 15" My 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Santa  Plush Christmas Stuffed Animal
Gund 15" My 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Santa Plush Christmas Stuffed Animal

$21.97

View Details
My Very Own Santa’s Workshop Wood Figures, Book & Puzzle Christmas Play Set NEW
My Very Own Santa’s Workshop Wood Figures, Book & Puzzle Christmas Play Set NEW

$14.00

View Details
Gund My 1st Christmas Plush Santa Rattle Easy Grip Toy For Infant Toy 6" GUC
Gund My 1st Christmas Plush Santa Rattle Easy Grip Toy For Infant Toy 6" GUC

$8.99

View Details
Step 2 My First Advent Calendar Christmas Countdown Complete Set With Box
Step 2 My First Advent Calendar Christmas Countdown Complete Set With Box

$200.00

View Details
12" Squishmallows Hello Kitty My Melody Santa Plush Doll Sanrio Christmas NWT
12" Squishmallows Hello Kitty My Melody Santa Plush Doll Sanrio Christmas NWT

$22.95

View Details
"My 1st Christmas" 18" Plush Gund Teddy Bear In Santa Suit
"My 1st Christmas" 18" Plush Gund Teddy Bear In Santa Suit

$14.00

View Details
VTG BANTAM CHRISTMAS SANTA CLAUS DOLL PLUSH TOY BIG "LISTEN TO MY CHIMES"
VTG BANTAM CHRISTMAS SANTA CLAUS DOLL PLUSH TOY BIG "LISTEN TO MY CHIMES"

$32.95

View Details
Disney Parks 9” Baby Mickey Mouse Plush My Baby's 1st First Christmas Santa Toy
Disney Parks 9” Baby Mickey Mouse Plush My Baby's 1st First Christmas Santa Toy

$12.75

View Details
Gund My First Christmas Bear Plush Christmas Holiday Santa Claus 13 Inch
Gund My First Christmas Bear Plush Christmas Holiday Santa Claus 13 Inch

$14.99

View Details
My Sister & I pattern #SR 603 Ragg-Bagg Santa 25" Christmas doll
My Sister & I pattern #SR 603 Ragg-Bagg Santa 25" Christmas doll

$9.15

View Details
NEW Mudpie Babies “My first Christmas Tree” Plush Toy W/Ornaments. #388
NEW Mudpie Babies “My first Christmas Tree” Plush Toy W/Ornaments. #388

$29.00

View Details
FRINGE Christmas Santa’s Pet Shop Eat My Powder  DINOSAUR Plush Squeaky -14”
FRINGE Christmas Santa’s Pet Shop Eat My Powder DINOSAUR Plush Squeaky -14”

$18.99

View Details
Baby Gund 13” White Teddy Bear In My First Christmas Santa Hat Rattle Plush
Baby Gund 13” White Teddy Bear In My First Christmas Santa Hat Rattle Plush

$16.00

View Details
Gund My 1st Christmas Bear 17" Tan Santa Hat Stuffed Animal Toy Soft Baby Gift
Gund My 1st Christmas Bear 17" Tan Santa Hat Stuffed Animal Toy Soft Baby Gift

$30.00

View Details
On My Way To Santa Claus Barn Toy Bag Balloons #62 Postcard
On My Way To Santa Claus Barn Toy Bag Balloons #62 Postcard

$8.00

View Details
Santa Claus Carter Child Of Mine Rattle Plush My First Christmas Baby Toy Lovey
Santa Claus Carter Child Of Mine Rattle Plush My First Christmas Baby Toy Lovey

$9.89

View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy

$96.90

View Details
Gund My 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Plush Soft Toy 14" Red White Santa First Gift
Gund My 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Plush Soft Toy 14" Red White Santa First Gift

$29.70

View Details