You May Like
LARGE 1950's Rubber Face 24" Santa Plush Doll My Toy Stuffed MCM Christmas
$145.00
View Details
Vintage My Toy Santa Claus 20" Velveteen Rubber Face Christmas Doll Plush 1950s
$79.99
View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24" Size Rushton Style
$98.50
View Details
VTG 1950s My Toy Rubber Face Plush Santa Claus 24" Doll Ruston Style
$150.00
View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa with Rubber Face, Hands, & Boots.
$63.00
View Details
Vintage MY Toy Christmas Large 24" Stuffed SANTA Plush Rubber Face Hands Boots
$70.00
View Details
"MY TOY"~ SANTA CLAUS MUSICAL Plush Doll~ Rubber Face ~1950's-60's Vintage
$79.00
View Details
Vtg 18” Rushton/My Toy ?Santa Claus Plush Christmas Rubber Face Original Belt
$149.00
View Details
Vintage Rare Large Plush 32” Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas My Toy 1960
$175.99
View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Lot Of 2 Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Christmas Rushton Dolls
$149.99
View Details
Vtg 50’s Large 24” Santa Rubber Face Hands Boots-Rushton ,My Toy ,Coca-Cola?
$76.00
View Details
24” Vintage MCM MY TOY Plush Stuffed Santa Rubber Face Hands Boots🎅🏻
$125.00
View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy SANTA CLAUS Plush Rubber Face Doll Rushton Style Large 20"
$74.99
View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Rubber Face Rushton Style 24”
$80.00
View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era
$179.99
View Details
Vintage Rubber Face Large Santa Claus Doll Plush “My Toy” 22" 1960s
$114.45
View Details
Vtg 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Push Rubber Face Hands Boot Ruston Style
$124.99
View Details
Vintage 1950's My Toy Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24" Size Rushton Style
$115.00
View Details
Vintage Christmas Santa Plush Doll Rubber Face & Plastic Boots My Toy 24" 1950's
$250.00
View Details
Vintage MY TOY Musical Santa Claus Plush Stuffed w/ Rubber Face Doll - 15" Tall
$79.99
View Details
Vintage Rubber Face Superior Toy Santa Korea Plush Doll Christmas Mcm Kitschy
$48.00
View Details
Tekky Toys Pull My Finger Santa Claus Plush 2004 Electronic Talking Farting Tags
$39.99
View Details
My Toy Rubber faced plush Santa Clause 30" vintage rare
$100.00
View Details
Tekky Toys Pull My Finger Santa Claus Plush 2002 Electronic Talking Farting
$38.00
View Details
Vintage 1950s Santa Claus My Toy Plush Rubber Face Doll With Original Tag
$199.99
View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 24"
$145.00
View Details
Vintage Rubber faced Santa My toy plush pals Vinyl 18" Tall
$124.95
View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
$92.99
View Details
Vtg 1950's My Toy Christmas Santa Claus Push Rubber Face Hands Boot Ruston Style
$189.97
View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Festive Music Playing Toy Lights & Sounds Christmas
$80.00
View Details
Vintage Large Plush 32” Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas Plastic 60s MCM Decor
$69.99
View Details
Stamped “1966 My Toy Co” Plush W/ Rubber Face Santa In Perfect Condition 15”.
$89.00
View Details
Vintage Santa Claus with Rubber Face,1950’s My Toy Santa, Christmas Kitsch
$75.00
View Details
My First Santa 2000 Plush Rattle Baby Pink Stuffed Green 1st Main Joy Toy
$25.00
View Details
Step2 ~ Step 2 ~ My First Advent Calendar ~ 25 Day Christmas Countdown ~ Retired
$74.99
View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Toy Music Lights Holiday Christmas Pretend Play NEW!!!
$55.96
View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
$114.99
View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
$91.45
View Details
NIB My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys
$12.00
View Details
MY FIRST SANTA CHRISTMAS RATTLE ?MAIN JOY? 2000 PLUSH TOY DOLL Pink Mint Green
$29.99
View Details
MCM Vintage Santa Claus Rubber Face Christmas Plush Large Stuffed 18" Smiling
$155.00
View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 24”
$149.95
View Details
Vintage MY TOY Stuffed Plush Santa Claus Rubber Hands Face Boots 927
$110.00
View Details
Pull My Finger Santa Plush Holiday Christmas Prank White Elephant Toy 7 In Gifts
$22.77
View Details
Santa's Workshop Plush Playset "My First Christmas" by Genius Babies
$12.96
View Details
Vintage My Toy 1950s Santa Claus doll-kitschy-Christmas-mid century
$150.00
View Details
NIB My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys
$9.99
View Details
Pearhead My First Christmas Santa Claus Security Blanket Plush Baby Toy Soft 13”
$8.00
View Details
1950s Rushton Toy Rubber Face Hands Boots Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 30”
$89.99
View Details
Sanrio Original My Melody Santa Claus Plush Toy 8"H (Christmas 2021) Japan
$42.87
View Details
Step2 My First Advent Calendar 25 Day Christmas Countdown Retired Brand New
$90.00
View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Festive Music Playing Toy Lights & Sounds Christmas
$49.99
View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Music Lights Holiday Xmas Pretend Play-NEW-FAST SHIP!
$99.98
View Details
SANRIO 8" MY MELODY Holiday Christmas Pink Santa Hat PLUSH NEW
$13.17
View Details
Antique Toy Rubber Face Hands Boots Santa Claus Christmas Plush Doll 24"
$81.17
View Details
BARK BOX Ho Ho Hold My Cookies DOG TOY Plush Multi NWT M-L Santa Claus Christmas
$24.58
View Details
My Oli Plush Bears in Christmas Santa Snowman & Reindeer 7” Ornaments Toys
$12.00
View Details
Christmas Lovey Santa My First Baby Starters Soothing Soft Security Baby Toy
$3.27
View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Music Lights Holiday Xmas Pretend Play-NEW-FAST SHIP!
$78.00
View Details
Kellytoy Baby My 1st Christmas Santa Teddy Bear Plush Rattle Crinkle Ears 10"
$12.95
View Details
Vintage Bantam Santa Plush Rattle Red Stuffed Baby Toy Lovey My 1st Xmas HTF 8”
$59.99
View Details
Baby Ganz “ My First Christmas “ Santa Outfit Plush Doll Rattle 9”
$7.50
View Details
Vtg 50s My Toy Santa Claus Plush Rubber Face Hand Boot Christmas Rushton Era 25"
$125.00
View Details
ANTIQUE CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT ~DOG IN SANTA TOY BAG~ "MY DARLING" on Belly
$22.99
View Details
My Life As Holiday Play Set Christmas Tree Fireplace For Use With 18" Dolls TM1
$63.99
View Details
Phidal My Busy Books Santa Claus Toy Mini Figure Christmas Holiday Ornament Rare
$3.99
View Details
My 1st Christmas Santa Snuggle Buddy Lovey Crib Activity Toy + Pacifier Clip
$8.79
View Details
My Little Pony Plush Blue Christmas Santa Hat Scarf Pinkie Pie Stuffed Animal 12
$18.69
View Details
Baby Gund My First Santa Lovie Plush Toy Rattle 11" Lovey Soft w/Sewn eyes
$9.99
View Details
Rare VTG 2011 Tekky Toys “My Ding-a-ling” Animated Elf New
$142.50
View Details
Jolijou Paris My First Santa Doll Plush Christmas Red Lovey NIB Stuffed 7.5" Toy
$27.00
View Details
My Favorite Things Vintage Plush Wieghted Velvet Santa Claus w/bag Hand Made
$24.99
View Details
Gotta Getta Gund My Name is Santa Stuffed Plush 12 Inch
$13.72
View Details
Step 2 My First Snowman Toy Music Lights Holiday Christmas Pretend Play Holiday
$35.00
View Details
My Little Pony Christmas Santa Hat Pinkie Pie 6" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2016
$3.99
View Details
VTG BANTAM CHRISTMAS SANTA CLAUS DOLL PLUSH TOY BIG "LISTEN TO MY CHIMES"
$16.14
View Details
VINTAGE CERAMIC SANTA KNOME FABRIC HAT TOY SACK KOREA 5"
$14.99
View Details
Teddy Bear Plush by Gund: "My First Christmas" 16" with Santa Suit
$9.45
View Details
Vintage 10 in tall Christmas Plastic Face Santa Claus Plush Posable Stuffed Doll
$24.25
View Details
My Little Pony Twilight Sparkle 6-Inch Plush Stuffed Toy with Santa Hat
$5.99
View Details
Gund 15" My 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Santa Plush Christmas Stuffed Animal
$21.97
View Details
My Very Own Santa’s Workshop Wood Figures, Book & Puzzle Christmas Play Set NEW
$14.00
View Details
Gund My 1st Christmas Plush Santa Rattle Easy Grip Toy For Infant Toy 6" GUC
$8.99
View Details
Step 2 My First Advent Calendar Christmas Countdown Complete Set With Box
$200.00
View Details
12" Squishmallows Hello Kitty My Melody Santa Plush Doll Sanrio Christmas NWT
$22.95
View Details
"My 1st Christmas" 18" Plush Gund Teddy Bear In Santa Suit
$14.00
View Details
VTG BANTAM CHRISTMAS SANTA CLAUS DOLL PLUSH TOY BIG "LISTEN TO MY CHIMES"
$32.95
View Details
Disney Parks 9” Baby Mickey Mouse Plush My Baby's 1st First Christmas Santa Toy
$12.75
View Details
Gund My First Christmas Bear Plush Christmas Holiday Santa Claus 13 Inch
$14.99
View Details
My Sister & I pattern #SR 603 Ragg-Bagg Santa 25" Christmas doll
$9.15
View Details
NEW Mudpie Babies “My first Christmas Tree” Plush Toy W/Ornaments. #388
$29.00
View Details
FRINGE Christmas Santa’s Pet Shop Eat My Powder DINOSAUR Plush Squeaky -14”
$18.99
View Details
Baby Gund 13” White Teddy Bear In My First Christmas Santa Hat Rattle Plush
$16.00
View Details
Gund My 1st Christmas Bear 17" Tan Santa Hat Stuffed Animal Toy Soft Baby Gift
$30.00
View Details
On My Way To Santa Claus Barn Toy Bag Balloons #62 Postcard
$8.00
View Details
Santa Claus Carter Child Of Mine Rattle Plush My First Christmas Baby Toy Lovey
$9.89
View Details
My Melody Santa Christmas Puroland Limited Mascot Plush Toy
$96.90
View Details
Gund My 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Plush Soft Toy 14" Red White Santa First Gift
$29.70
View Details